After Reading Emerson's idea's and views about the way people live in the 1800's, it is safe to say that people have conducted themselves with the same indignity for centuries. Emerson is quoted saying, "There is a time in every man's education when he arrives at the conviction that envy is ignorance; that imitation is suicide; that he must take himself for better, for worse". This quote is disturbing to me, it shows that the idea of plentitude and people not being satisfied with themselves is not concentrated to the 21st century. Why is it that we envy people who are "better" than us or more successful? Is it possible that it is just human nature to act in such a way? If you ask me it is a direct result of people always being told they need to do better, or they need to make more money, because money and success equal happiness. This of course is not true, my family is not wealthy but we get by as middle class citizens, yet, I personally do not need material possessions or money to be happy, nor do i want them for some sort of rank in class. The problem is that many Americans do not have this mindset, most American think an H3 and a multimillion dollar mansion are the key to happiness.
Henry Thoreau had the same kind of mindset as myself. He took a year of his life to live "deliberately" in the woods in Massachusetts, and see what he could learn from the way life should be experienced. I found this very interesting because i sometimes wish I could experience this myself. I think i could survive in the woods for a year considering i grew up in the boondocks of New Jersey withs farms surrounding me. I could easily deal with the lack of technology, but not having certain possessions would be a tough pill to swallow. From an experience like this, one can learn much about who one truly is, and how they have the ability to survive and pass time all alone. There are plenty of things in nature to experience, not to mention you would have to do EVERYTHING yourself i.e: washing clothes, making utensils, hunting and fishing for food, and bearing the elements.
As the course moves along, it is becoming easier to make direct connections between the texts we have been reading. In a way Thoreau and Emerson are historic versions of Lasn and Anderson, in the sense that there message is the same. I take "Culture Jam" and "Feed" as a way for the authors to cleverly warn readers about the fast-paced dangerous direction our nation is moving in. If trends continue Lasn and Anderson's warnings will be looked straight through, much like Thoreau and Emerson, because we have progressively gotten worse since the works of E&T.
Great connections between texts! Your point about Thoreau and Emerson being historic versions of Lasn and Anderson really stuck out to me. I think that judging by our class discussions, you're right. You probably could live without some of the necessities you enjoy today. But would you really be living deliberately and seizing every moment? Or just passing time and counting the days until you can rejoin society? Just something to think about!
ReplyDeleteDave I second Lindsay, great connections between the texts. I too see the connections but wonder if we will ever see a difference in this world. As E&T saw it then and we still have changed after Feed, Culture Jams, and the dumbest Gen Y. Will we ever really truly change or will we end up with a computer implanted in our heads 250 years from now, kinda scary. If you were to go to the woods.. Would you miss your gamming system you play and love? I know that has to keep some of your time and I’m sure even though reading all these readings it hasn’t changed your gamming usage. Or has it? I’m currently working on the challenge and I have to say it’s hard not having my cell phone for a few things but I’m not missing TV or Facebook at all. I’m currently taking 5 classes with 3 of them have huge projects and my kids are keeping me busy enough that I haven’t even thought about not having facebook or TV. Great post looking forward to the next.
ReplyDeleteYou're connections were great! I loved this quote "most American think an H3 and a multimillion dollar mansion are the key to happiness." This is totally true in our society. I saw this in my two best guy friends this weekend. My one friend was complaining about his old jeep that he has and how it was so old and how he wants this new mustang or whatever and my other friend just looks at him and says it still runs doesnt it? why get a new car when it still gets you from A to B.
ReplyDeleteI really liked your post! I hate how people think money buys happiness. I have everything I need in my life right now and I'm very happy and content. I don't think I could live in the woods for a year like he did, though. I love the outdoors and would love to do what he did for like a weekend but not a whole year. I feel like we could learn a lot if we just did what he did for a weekend or so. It'd surprise people.
ReplyDeleteGreat post, I am surprised you think you could live in the woods for a year by yourself. I agree that you could go without the technology but it would be difficult going without certain things. But what about the people, you talk about being rid of material things but would you be able to stand being alone with no human contact?
ReplyDelete